About Our Agency

Carey Insurance Agency, Inc. provides comprehensive insurance options.

We are your trusted independent insurance agency.

Home » About Our Agency

Your family, your business, and your possessions are all important to you, but you may not know how to best protect them. We have the experience to navigate the unique risks you face, serving as your insurance advisor.

Carey Insurance Agency, Inc. is a local, family-owned independent insurance agency that was founded in 2005. Since that time, we have worked to make you our priority. We are committed to helping you find the right insurance coverage for the right price by working with you to understand what matters most to you.

You can feel confident that you’re working with an experienced staff who are focused on helping you find peace of mind. Our agency has won multiple ERIE Life Recognition Awards and Founders’ Awards over the years for our dedication to our clients. We are also members of IA&B, which means we have access to resources to help meet your needs. You can also feel confident that you’re working with an agency that also cares about our community. Our staff is involved in organizations like the Old Forge Lions Club and the Old Forge Sons of Italy, working to better our communities any way they can.

We specialize in home insurance, auto insurance, renters insurance, and motorcycle insurance. Because we’re independent, our priority is you—not the insurance company. We represent many different insurance companies that offer a wide variety of coverage options and price points. Our goal is to deliver the right blend of price, coverage, and service.

Our Mission Statement

At Carey Insurance Agency, Inc., we’re committed to making the needs of our customers our number one priority by providing quality insurance products backed by an attentive and experienced staff.

Why Go Independent?
About Our Agency - Aerial View of a River Running Through Green Mountains and Farmland With Clouds Casting Shadows on the Landscape

Get Started Today

As an independent agency, we are here to help you find the right coverage.

Get a Quote

The Advantage of an Independent Agency Working for You

What makes our independent agency different?

  • Personalized insurance solutions.
  • Friendly, knowledgeable service.
  • Building trusted relationships.
Find Out How

Get the power of choice when it comes to finding the right insurance for your situation. We offer a wide variety of policies and price points to choose from.


Rely on us to simplify the insurance process, from advising you on your risks and solutions, to advocating on your behalf to the insurance company.


Count on us to be there for you every step of the way with personable and professional service so you always have the right coverage for your insurance needs.

Insurance Solutions We Specialize In

We specialize in a variety of coverage options to meet your unique insurance needs.

  Request an Insurance Quote

As an independent agency, we are here to help you find the right coverage.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Get a Quote

It only takes a minute to get started.

  • Fill out the form, we’ll be in touch.
  • Go over your options with an agent.
  • Get the coverage you need.

Would you rather discuss this in person? Get in touch with an agent today!